We’ve see a good amount of competition amongst the barking methods. A good amount of dog owners go with citronella collars rather than shock collars. Still, some owners won’t use anything but the shock collar. Below we will find out more about citronella collar and shock collar compared.
Citronella Bark Collar Or Dog Shock Collar?
While contrasting citronella dog collar vs. dog shock collars we will look into the safety of these collar, are they humane way to stop dog barking and finally, do they achieve what they suppose to be doing, namely stop dog barking.
While it is definitely known that citronella collar is considered a mild and the safest and most humane bark collars quite a few nevertheless subscribe to the notion that citronella dog collar can also be extremely effective or even more precisely citronella collar can be twice better than the shock collar or 4 times the effectiveness of ultrasonic collars.
This is precisely what the results of the study performed at Cornell’s College of Veterinary Medicine’s Animal Behavior Clinic shows. As per the results, citronella collar was discovered to be efficient at stopping barking completely or minimizing nuisance barking up to 88%, or twice as efficient as dog shock collar and also 4x more successful than ultrasonic collar.
How Come Citronella Bark Collar Is Far Better Than Dog Shock Collars?
It would appear that many reasons exist as to why citronella dog collar works better than the shock collar. Many believe it is due to the fact citronella collar doesn’t result in any pain and therefore doesn’t create any kind of stress that, according to a few, may be the cause of dogs barking in the first place.
Many people talk about the fact dogs have extremely evolved sense of smell and for that reason consider the smell from the citronella dog collar extremely irritating and bothersome.
Lastly the assertion is formed that citronella collar has an effect on four of the dog’s five sensory faculties. The dog hears the noise from the citronella dog collar, then sees the spray of citronella, feels the mist and finally, smells it.
One must mention that there have been many advancements with both the citronella collar and the shock collar. In many situations veterinarians and dog trainers are also recommending the dog shock collar for bark training.
While the citronella collar is regarded as far better than the dog shock collar you can find situations when citronella dog collar might not function well with every dog and perhaps the dog shock collar could have greater effects. It truly is up to each dog owner to determine which specific dog bark collar fits their specific needs.
We recommend always discussing each solution with your veterinarian or dog trainer. There are many publications available on the subject of dog bark collars available for researching the best solution as well.
Citronella Dog Collar vs. Dog Shock Collar-The Outcome?
Currently it appears that citronella dog collar is the obvious champion above dog shock collars. Even so, as already pointed out, some dog owners will have more success using the dog shock collar and not much with citronella dog collar. So, which one is better for you-citronella dog collar or dog shock collar?
 Multivet AntiBark Collar, Deluxe |
 Spray Commander Remote Trainer |
 Tri-Tronics Bark Limiter XS |
 PetSafe Deluxe Spray Bark Collar, PSBC-300 |
